Defining Fair Market Value

Need aid with an appraisal? Search our database of ISA members to find a or commercial property appraiser near you. Find an ISA Member « 

Much of us remember sitting in Core Course and remembering, yes, remembering, the Federal definition of Fair Market price (FMV). This was back when the Core Course examination was brief essay, fill-in-the-blank, and multiple choice. Now the examination is numerous choice and memorizing the meaning is not a requirement to passing the exam. However, if you were one of individuals who memorized the meaning, do not stop checking out! FMV is probably a little bit more complicated than you keep in mind. First, there can be multiple definitions of reasonable market value depending upon the planned use of the report, and maybe the state or province that you live in. Second, although there is just one Federal meaning of FMV, you ought to point out the definition of FMV differently depending upon the planned usage of the appraisal report.

The Definition of Fair Market Price

Let’s start with the federal meaning of FMV and a short history lesson. The very first place to discover guidance is within the IRS policies.

A very long time ago (pre-1985), the meaning of FMV for a noncash charitable contributions was just:

The definition of FMV for estates was a somewhat various and a broadened definition. It came from the Estate Tax Regulations:

So, while the definitions were similar, the IRS argued that there were differences in between the 2 definitions. In 1985, the IRS lost that argument in court. In Anselmo v. Commissioner, 757 F. 2d 1208 (11th Cir. 1985), the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals verifying the Tax Court held that « there need to be no difference in between the step of reasonable market price for estate and present tax and charitable contribution functions. » Therefore, when figuring out fair market value for any federal function, the complete meaning of fair market price applies. (Learn more in the updated 2018-2019 ISA Core Course Manual, 2-3 through 2-8). This means that an appraiser must mention the complete meaning of FMV in their appraisal report. But, what is the best way to point out the definition?

ISA’s Core Course Manual recommends the following language for your charitable donation reports:

Keep in mind that the efficient date for a charitable contribution is the date of contribution or awaited date of donation. The date of contribution is the date that the charity accepts legal title to the item. Often there is a deed of present documenting this transaction. If possible, it is good to include a copy of the deed of gift in the addendum of the appraisal report.

For estates, the Core Course Manual recommends the language:

The reliable date for a taxable estate is the date of death or the alternate valuation date (i.e., 6 months after the date of death). The appraiser must ask the client which date the estate is choosing. Generally, which date is picked has more to do with stock appraisal than the value of the personal residential or commercial property unless there has actually been a big change in market conditions.

As an aside, Anselmo also clarified what is suggested by « the public. » The court stated that « the general public » refers to « the popular purchasers of an item. » The most appropriate purchaser of a product is not usually the specific consumer. For example, the basic purchasing public for live cattle would be consisted of mainly of slaughterhouses instead of individual consumers. The fair market price of live livestock accordingly would be measured by the rate paid at the animals auction instead of at the supermarket. In this case, the Tax Court discovered the « public » for low quality, unmounted gems to be the jewelry producer and precious jewelry shops that develop fashion jewelry products, rather than the individual customer. The 11th Circuit affirmed this finding. So, understanding the appropriate market for the items you are evaluating is crucial to identifying a precise reasonable market value.

Oh Canada …

The meaning of reasonable market price in Canada is similar to that in the United States, but varies a little. The Canada Revenue Agency and the Canadian Cultural Residential Or Commercial Property Export Review Board have backed this meaning of reasonable market price:

Note that in Canada, the « highest cost » does not mean the highest rate ever achieved. It suggests the greatest cost that is consistently achieved near the effective date of the report. Just as in the United States, the appraiser must be taking a look at the mode (i.e., the most common accomplished cost). However, in Canada if there is a « modal range » (i.e., a variety of commonly accomplished costs) the appraiser may select a number at the top of that variety. In the U.S. the appraiser would likely pick a number in the middle of that range.

One other distinction is that in the U.S. the appraiser determines fair market value. However, in Canada, the appraiser estimates reasonable market price and the government figures out fair market value.

Other Definitions of Fair Market Value

Appraisers need to also understand that various meanings of fair market worth may exist for different functions which these meanings might vary from state to state or province to province. For instance, in the 4 or five states where I have actually done divorce work the residential or commercial property was to be valued at « fair market price » per state statute. However, none of the statutes defined fair market price. So, what definition do you utilize?

The primary step is constantly to ask the client or the customer’s lawyer if there is a particular definition that they would like you to utilize, either from the state statutes or regulations governing divorce law or from the case law (i.e., the legal cases that have actually been chosen and published). Sometimes they can email you the meaning to use together with the proper legal citation. If you get a definition, use it and the appropriate legal citation in the appraisal report. Note that # 14 on the ISA Report Checklist requires not just the definition of the value sought but also the suitable citation.

In my experience, nevertheless, a question about the state meaning of FMV is frequently consulted with silence (you can hear crickets in the background). When this happens, the appraiser can recommend utilizing the federal definition of reasonable market price used for estates, present tax and charitable contributions. In almost all circumstances where I have suggested this, the lawyer has actually concurred. You can use either of the complete meanings above. I typically omit the language about the « decedent’s gross estate » in the 2nd definition due to the fact that it is irrelevant to a divorce scenario.

The effective date for a divorce appraisal varies from one state to another. In many states, it is the date of separation. However, I have used the date of separation, the date of evaluation, or the date of the report relying on the requirements of the client and their attorney. Ultimately, it depends on the client’s attorney to make a legal decision as to what the suitable date need to be.

Fair market price may also come into play in a tort match (i.e., a suit handling a civil wrong that might include a negligence or similar claim). In most tort fits the definition of reasonable market value will originate from case law. Again, ask the lawyer what definition you need to utilize and get the appropriate citation. Also ask what the efficient date should be.